Evidence is not a score. “Comparative” means evidence is available; “guide claim” and “historical” preserve the source’s judgment. Disputed, unresolved and modified records are not stock-watch endorsements.
How to read this atlas
“1:1” is not a verified finding of this research. The useful question is which exact reference, factory and generation has traceable evidence of close reproduction—and what still differs. NWBIG is a community value judgment; its meaning is not uniform across guides.
What is new
This edition adds 47 source-qualified records to the previous 375-record archive. They include six-factory Submariner testing, original RWG genuine comparisons for the Tank, Santos, Daytona, Hulk, AP 15500 and Seamaster; conditional Panerai generation ratings; ownership reports; smaller-watch guide omissions; and current Cartier/Railmaster checks.
The review library has 63 entries, including all 21 brand-index links recovered from RWI’s Brand Review Index. The RWI team advertises more than 430 reviews. Those 430+ reviews have not all been read or classified here. Index-only discoveries are explicitly ungraded.
The most important new comparison
In RWI’s June 2026 six-factory Submariner comparison, the author’s total includes price and favors RICH. The other four price-excluded scorers all put genuine first; RICH and VSF frequently lead the replicas. This supports considering both factories, not calling a replica objectively superior or literally identical. PureTime photo material is disclosed despite the author’s statement that no gifts or sponsorship were involved.
Read the original RWI comparison ↗
Evidence, not a popularity vote
Comparative evidence means a comparison exists; it does not automatically mean the replica passed. Guide claim preserves a reported classification. Historical applies only to the stated older configuration. Disputed / unresolved is deliberately not an endorsement. Modified separates improved builds from factory stock.
Dealer-authored comparisons can be informative, but commercial interest is disclosed. Copied guides, the same author’s cross-posts and dealer reproductions are not counted as independent confirmation. Genuine-side authentication examples are counterevidence to universal claims, but their unknown factories cannot be used to condemn a particular current factory.
What is not established
No uniform material verification, water-resistance test, accuracy distribution, long-term defect-rate study, blinded detection trial, live-stock verification or genuine-equivalent servicing guarantee covers this catalog. A free-sprung balance, genuine Swiss base movement, or a weight-matched case alone establishes none of those things.
Coverage and limits
The searchable guide covers 260 model/configuration groups and 422 evidence records across 27 brands. Groups overlap where generations, alternatives, sizes or contradictory sources must remain separate; they are not 260 unique approved watches. All 189 original expanded entries are preserved. The coverage register also records seven investigated brands without a sufficiently established award.
This is a broad public-web research snapshot dated 31 October 2026, not a literal archive of the entire internet. Forum access is uneven; only inspected bodies are treated as substantive review evidence. Source dates distinguish historical knowledge from newer guide changes.
Practical reading order
Begin with the 24 starting points, then switch to all groups and filter by brand or assessment. Open a card’s evidence to see exactly what supports it. Use the Review Library for newer ungraded developments rather than treating every new release as an automatic upgrade.